Kim Crumbo was born in 1947 and spent four years with the Navy's SEAL Team One, completing two combat deployments to Vietnam (Rewilding Institute). The Salt Lake Tribune reported that he received a Bronze Star and that his unit received a Presidential Unit Citation (Peterson). After the war he turned to rivers. He worked about ten years as a professional guide, beginning in the Grand Canyon, and then served twenty years with the National Park Service there, first as a river ranger and later as wilderness coordinator (Rewilding Institute; Peterson). In 1981 he published A River Runner's Guide to the History of the Grand Canyon (Crumbo and French). Later he turned to conservation advocacy. He co-founded the Grand Canyon Wildlands Council, which became part of Wild Arizona, and at the time of his death he was wildlands coordinator for the Rewilding Institute in New Mexico (Peninsula Daily News; Peterson).
Mark O'Neill was born in 1954 to the same mother as Crumbo, Patricia Elliott, who had children by three different fathers. His sister Toni Kelly told a reporter that her family never used the word "half" (Thuermer). The Park Service itself first called the men half-brothers, then issued a correction stating that they were brothers (National Park Service). O'Neill guided in the Grand Canyon in the 1970s and served there as a seasonal river ranger. He then worked twenty years at Olympic National Park in Washington, retiring in 2016 (Lawton; Thuermer). Colleagues credited him with swiftwater rescues and recoveries (Lawton). In September 2021 the two men were 74 and 67 years old, with decades of experience between them on cold, fast water.
Shoshone Lake lies at the head of the Lewis River, southwest of West Thumb. The Park Service gives its area as 8,050 acres and describes it as the park's second-largest lake, with no road access (National Park Service). Thuermer reports a maximum depth of about 205 feet and describes a lake roughly six and a half miles long whose axis lies along the prevailing southwest wind, with a constriction called The Narrows near its middle. Park officials told him that wind accelerates through that gap and that waves of three to four feet are common, a point consistent with the park's boating guidance, which he quotes (Thuermer).
The cold is the principal hazard. The Park Service puts the lake's average temperature at about 48 degrees Fahrenheit and the survival time of an immersed person at only twenty to thirty minutes (National Park Service). The surface at The Narrows measured 53 degrees on September 22, 2021, and searchers recorded 44 degrees near the bottom (Thuermer). Thuermer also reports that at least eight people had drowned or died of hypothermia on the lake before 2021, including a seasonal Yellowstone ranger, Ryan Weltman, lost in 1994 and a Casper man lost in 1958 whose body was never recovered. These figures rest on his reporting alone.
According to Thuermer, O'Neill left Chimacum on September 9, 2021, towing a canoe he called ShoLew, and drove to Crumbo's home in Ogden. The two left Ogden on Sunday, September 12, and reached the Lewis Lake area that afternoon. Their backcountry permit covered four nights beginning the next day, but the roadside campground was full and the weather was calm. Investigators believe they may have launched that evening, a theory that cannot be confirmed (Thuermer). Their plan was to paddle Lewis Lake, work the canoe up the Lewis River channel, and camp at reserved sites along Shoshone's shore.
The best evidence of their location comes from a backpacker who photographed two men in a canoe on the lake's west side on the afternoon of September 13. Yellowstone investigators told Thuermer that the photograph is poor and cannot establish the boat's identity. O'Neill's widow, Karin Lowrie, believes it shows her husband and brother-in-law. That photograph, if it is theirs, is the last known sighting. Searchers later found the men's camp at South Narrow Point, on the south shore. Food was hung properly, no bear tracks were found, and the meal-by-meal food cache suggested that the men had spent one night there (Thuermer).
The weather was poor. Thuermer cites storms between September 13 and 16 that kept experienced boaters off the lake, and a West Yellowstone station recorded a 16-mile-per-hour southwest wind that afternoon. Rebecca Lawton, a former Grand Canyon river ranger who knew both men, wrote that an early snowstorm brought 45-mile-per-hour winds and waves of at least two feet. Her figures are secondhand, and the sources disagree on the wind speed (Lawton; Thuermer).
Family members reported the men overdue on Sunday, September 19. The Park Service found a vacant campsite with gear on the south shore and a canoe, paddle, personal flotation device, and other belongings on the east shore (National Park Service). Thuermer places the first find, a red life vest with the name Kim written inside, within hours of the alert. The Park Service news release dates the camp's discovery to September 19, while Thuermer describes searchers reaching it the following day. The accounts differ on that detail and agree on the rest.
On Monday, September 20, rangers found O'Neill's body in a small cove on the east shore. Thuermer reports that he lay face down with one arm through an unzipped life vest. An autopsy attributed his death to exposure, meaning hypothermia, and the Park Service announced the finding on September 29 (National Park Service). Thuermer notes that the canoe's thwart was broken and that light debris associated with it had drifted to the north shore near The Narrows. Park officials guessed that the capsize occurred somewhere on the lake's west side, though they described this as speculation. Chief Ranger Chris Flesch told Thuermer that Yellowstone could not say whether the men were wearing their vests when they went into the water.
The effort began with a ten-person ground crew and a Grand Teton National Park helicopter on September 21 (National Park Service). After five days of sweeping trails, searching the shoreline by boat, and gridding open water from the air, the park reclassified the operation as a recovery on September 24. The Park Service's Submerged Resources Center began sonar work that day, and dog teams from Western Montana Search Dogs joined later (National Park Service). Thuermer reports that fifty-nine searchers worked twenty consecutive days, and that boats were airlifted to the lake because it has no road.
On October 8, with snow and freezing temperatures forecast, the park announced it was scaling back the search. It said limited efforts would continue as conditions allowed and that it did not expect further updates unless something changed (National Park Service). The Standard-Examiner of Ogden reported temperatures in the twenties and a blanket of snow in the park the following week (Vandenack). According to Thuermer, Superintendent Cam Sholly returned to the lake alone on October 9 and walked most of the east shore for six hours, finding nothing.
The Park Service said in 2021 that the incident remained under investigation. Thuermer reported in 2023 that investigators had found no evidence of foul play and that, because the case was open, the records were not public. A person reading the public record must therefore separate what was observed from what was inferred.
Observed: two experienced paddlers entered a cold lake during unsettled weather in an open canoe. One was found dead of hypothermia and the other has not been found. Inferred: the canoe swamped or capsized on open water, most likely in the lake's west lobe, and the cold incapacitated the men within minutes. That inference comes from park officials and is consistent with the physical evidence, but no one saw it happen. Becky Crumbo, Kim's wife, told the Tribune that she believed a sudden squall had struck, and that she did not think anything sinister had occurred (Peterson). Some friends were less certain, and Karin Lowrie told a Washington newspaper that she thought the brothers had been caught by something unexpected (Vandenack). None of these views amounts to evidence.
The wording of one source deserves caution. Thuermer's account reports a plausible track for the men's last hours, but the Park Service's own releases do not name a cause of the capsize or a location. Claims about where and why it happened should be treated as informed estimates.
The family established a memorial fund, Kim Crumbo's Fund for the Wild, to support four conservation organizations that he had worked with (Rewilding Institute). The Rewilding Institute continued to publish his draft proposals after his disappearance, including a wildlife corridor plan for the Grand Staircase region (Peterson). As of the most recent public reporting located for this article, Crumbo has not been found.
The episode has an instructive feature. Both men held credentials that most recreational paddlers lack, and they had been through worse than a mountain lake. The Park Service's own warnings describe the conditions that the lake can produce, and the men had received those warnings with their permit (Thuermer). What the record shows is not recklessness. It shows how little margin any boater has on a lake that cold, and how little the record can say about the moments in which it was lost.
Crumbo, Kim, and Llyn French. A River Runner's Guide to the History of the Grand Canyon. Johnson Books, 1981.
Lawton, Rebecca. "A Community of River Guides Copes with Loss." Jackson Hole News&Guide, 17 Nov. 2021, https://www.jhnewsandguide.com/jackson_hole_daily/state_and_regional/guest_opinion/a-community-of-river-guides-copes-with-loss/article_93c12714-4328-5297-8805-c471e2b289e1.html. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.
National Park Service. "Yellowstone National Park Scales Back Search and Recovery of Shoshone Lake Canoer." News release, Yellowstone National Park, 8 Oct. 2021 (includes updates of 21 Sept. through 29 Sept. 2021), https://www.nps.gov/yell/learn/news/21027.htm. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.
Peninsula Daily News. "Yellowstone Crews Scale Back Search for Utah Conservationist." The Associated Press, 17 Oct. 2021, https://www.peninsuladailynews.com/?p=194036. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.
Peterson, Kolbie. "What Happened to Kim Crumbo?" The Salt Lake Tribune, 15 Nov. 2021, https://www.sltrib.com/news/2021/11/15/what-happened-kim-crumbo/. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.
Rewilding Institute. "Kim Crumbo, 1947-2021." Rewilding, https://rewilding.org/kim-crumbo/. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.
Sierra Club Utah Chapter. "A Tragic Accident Claims the Life of a Dear Friend." Sierra Club, 3 Oct. 2021, https://www.sierraclub.org/utah/blog/2021/10/tragic-accident-claims-life-dear-friend. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.
Thuermer, Angus M., Jr. "The Boys and the Lake: How Two Backcountry Experts Met Death in Yellowstone." WyoFile, 13 Sept. 2023, https://wyofile.com/the-boys-and-the-lake-how-two-backcountry-experts-met-death-in-yellowstone/. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.
Vandenack, Tim. "National Park Service Scales Back Search for Kim Crumbo, Ogden Conservationist." Standard-Examiner, 13 Oct. 2021, https://www.standard.net/news/government/2021/oct/13/national-park-service-scales-back-search-for-kim-crumbo-ogden-conservationist/. Accessed 28 Oct. 2026.